Skip to main content

LexisNexis Corporate Rescue and Insolvency: Case Alerter – October 2026

Articles
17 Nov 2026

At-a-glance case summaries provided by the Gatehouse Chambers’ Insolvency Team, featuring:

  • Elevate Estates Management Ltd v Fine Star Ltd [2026] EWHC 1831 (Ch)
  • Next Generation Holdings Ltd v Finch [2026] EWCA Civ 1015

Read the latest CRI Cases Alerter authored by Wendy Parker and Rory Cochrane below.


Elevate Estates Management Ltd v Fine Star Ltd[2026] EWHC 1831 (Ch)

This judgment of Chief ICC Judge Briggs concerns applications made by Elevate Estates Management Ltd against a winding-up petition brought by Fine Star Ltd. The court ultimately ruled against Elevate on all major issues. The judgment followed a list of authorities which confirm the necessity of Applicants seeking to restrain presentation and/or advertisement of petitions to be supported by contemporaneous corroborative evidence.

It is of course correct that the test is whether there is a genuine triable issue: see Ashworth v Newnote [2007] BPIR 1012 at [35]. However, this court is well used to scrutinising defences and evidence given on oath to determine whether it really does give rise to a genuine issue. In particular, in Portsmouth v Alldays Franchising Ltd  [2005] BPIR 1394, Patten J (at para 12) makes it clear that the court is able togo behind the evidence of the debtor or creditor:

“So far as the evidence is concerned the mere fact that a party in proceedings not involving oral evidence or cross-examination asserts that certain things did or did not occur, is not sufficient in itself to raise a triable issue. That evidence inevitably has to be considered against the background of all the other admissible evidence and material in order to judge whether it is an allegation of any substance. Once the court considers that the evidence is reliable in that sense, and not some attempt to obfuscate the real issues by raising a series of hopeless allegations then it does, of course, become necessary to consider what the legal consequences of it are.”

In Wagner v White (2018) EWCH 2882 (Ch) Mr Justice Nugee adopted the statement by Arden LJ in Collier v P & M J Wright (Holdings) Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 1329 at [21], that it is not enough to succeed in an application to set aside a statutory demand to point to an arguable dispute. There has to be something to suggest that the assertion is sustainable, and it is open to the court to reject the applicant’s version of events if it is inherently implausible or if it is contradicted, or not supported, by contemporaneous documentation.

Background

  • Fine Star was the landlord under 51 leases granted to Elevate.
  • Elevate was required to pay fixed rent regardless of whether it received rent from its own tenants.
  • By the time the winding-up petition was presented (23 June 2026), rent arrears were stated to be £836,557.23, rising to £1,120,586.87 by 7 July 2026.

Chief ICC Judge Briggs found that:

  • Elevate produced no convincing evidence showing that £1.76m of payments had been omitted from Fine Star’s records.
  • The repair claim of £334,376.23 was unsupported by invoices, contracts, or evidence that the works were carried out.
  • The only documented repair discussions related to a much smaller amount (around £17,938).
  • Even if the repair claim had merit, it would not eliminate the substantial debt owed to Fine Star.

The court held that:

  • There was no genuine or substantial dispute regarding the debt.
  • There was no genuine or substantial cross-claim.
  • The winding-up petition was not bound to fail.
  • Elevate had failed to demonstrate that a validation order wouldprotect creditors.

As to Costs, the judge ordered that:

  • Elevate must pay Fine Star’s legal costs. Costs would be assessed on the indemnity basis, the judge concluding that Elevate’s applications were “totally without merit” and unsupported by sufficient evidence, taking the case “beyond the norm”.

OF INTEREST

At para 23 of his judgment, ICC Briggs stated:

“23. In argument my attention was also drawn to Tallington Lakes v South Kesteven District Council [2012] EWCA Civ 443, which is often cited to argue that the threshold test for a restraining order is lower than that applied to summary judgment. Etherton LJ said:
‘it is well established that the threshold for establishing that a debt is disputed on substantial grounds in the context of a winding up petition is not a high one for restraining the presentation of the winding up petition, and may be reached even if, on an application for summary judgment, the defencecould be regarded as “shadowy”’. 24. In so far as Tallington Lakes is relevant to restraining notice or advertisement, I do not read Etherton LJ as saying that a restraining order would be made if the defence is ‘shadowy’. The term ‘shadowy’ is famously imprecise so that one may say ‘one knows it when one sees it’. It must be appreciated that although the decision is one of the Court of Appeal, there was no representation from the respondent; Etherton LJ sat alone; and the decision was made on an oral renewal application for permission to appeal. It should not be lost on practitioners that the judgment is prohibited from being cited under two of the grounds provided by para 6.2 of the Practice Direction (Citation of Authorities) [2001] 1WLR 1001.”


Next Generation Holdings Ltd v Finch [2026] EWCA Civ 1015
Court: Court of Appeal (Civil Division), Judge(s): Snowden LJ, Peter Jackson LJ, Bean LJ

FACTS

This case arose out of the acquisition by Next Generation Holdings Ltd (NGHL) of AFL Insurance Brokers Ltd (AFL), an FCAauthorised wholesale broker in September 2017. Following the acquisition, NGHL discovered it had been induced by fraudulent misrepresentations to purchase the shares in AFL. NGHL discovered that from August 2011, AFL’s directors (Alex and Bob Finch), had caused AFL to draw on client money to meet its expenses and trading losses and, with the CFO, entered false income accruals to conceal the drawings. AFL was insolvent on both bases from at least 30 June 2014; by the time of NGHL’s acquisition of AFL the client money deficit stood at £3.51m. Following the sale of AFL in September 2017, AFL’s management uncovered the fraud in April 2020, following which AFL borrowed to make good the client accounts, then entered into a solvent wind-down and sold its business.

HHJ Johns KC found the Finches liable to NGHL in deceit and for breach of warranty (£3.22m), and to AFL for dishonest breach of s 172(1) Companies Act 2006 and unlawful means conspiracy. Treating the client money deficit as a “proxy” for pre-sale trading losses, and reasoning by analogy with the wrongful trading cases, the
judge awarded AFL £7.11m of trading losses from 1 July 2014 to 2021, less credit of £2.85m for the business sale proceeds. Permission to appeal was granted only in respect of AFL’s claim, in relation to the question whether the Finches’ fraud had caused losses to AFL (leaving the award to NGHL untouched).

DECISION

Snowden LJ delivered the judgment of the Court of Appeal (with Lords Justice Bean and Peter Jackson agreeing).

The duties of the directors

Snowden LJ first considered the nature of the breach of duty of the directors. No mismanagement of AFL’s business had been alleged, nor any misapplication of AFL’s own assets; the Finches’ breach was taking clients’ money to pay AFL’s liabilities and hiding it by false accounting. Therefore, to the extent the judge treated the directors’ conduct in causing AFL “to trade at a loss” as itself a breach of s 172(1) or as unlawful means, that was wrong. Directors do not, without more, owe fiduciary duties not to trade at a loss or while insolvent (Secretary of State v Gash [1997] 1 WLR 407; BTI 2014 LLC v Sequana SA [2022] UKSC 25), and it is not unlawful to trade in the circumstances described in s 214 Insolvency Act 1986, which merely conditions a contribution order on an insolvent liquidation or administration that AFL never entered (at [35]-[42]). No Sequana breach was pleaded or found: the essence of the fraud was that AFL’s creditors were paid, albeit with clients’ money.

Causation

As to the central appeal issue of causation, Snowden LJ observed that the judge had adopted too “broad brush” an approach and did not focus on the necessary relationship between the breaches of duty and the trading losses claimed. “But for” causation was a necessary but not sufficient condition of liability. The principles applying to causation in negligence (and, similarly, to equitable compensation for breach of fiduciary duty not involving misapplied trust property) also applied to unlawful means conspiracy. AFL’s trading losses arose independently from its dealings with counterparties; what was wrongful was that the Finches sought to use client money to fill
the “hole”. The Finches’ breaches of duty in misappropriating client money had the direct consequence that AFL became liable in equity as a trustee to restore the trust fund at its own expense by repaying the monies that had been misappropriated. That liability to make up the “hole” of £3.51m in the client money accounts was a loss to AFL that was directly caused by the Finches’ breaches of duty. The judge should have held the Finches liable to AFL for causing that direct loss, rather than using the hole in the client money account as an indirect “proxy” for trading losses.

Disclaimer

This content is provided free of charge for information purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied on as such. No responsibility for the accuracy and/or correctness of the information and commentary set out in the article, or for any consequences of relying on it, is assumed or accepted by any member of Chambers or by Chambers as a whole.

Contact

Please note that we do not give legal advice on individual cases which may relate to this content other than by way of formal instruction of a member of Gatehouse Chambers. However, if you have any other queries about this content please contact:

Ashley Allen
Ashley Allen Head of MarketingTel: 020 7691 0032