Skip to main content

Nigel Jones KC, Sarah McCann KC and Charles Simpson successful in Privy Council in Enterprise Insurance v Flowers

Gatehouse Chambers’ Nigel Jones KC, Sarah McCann KC and Charles Simpson (instructed by Triay Lawyers) have succeeded before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council on behalf of their client Enterprise Insurance Company Plc (in liquidation).

The judgment handed down today (17/11/26) is the latest development in long-running litigation arising from Gibraltar’s largest ever insurer insolvency; the Gatehouse team having acted for Enterprise’s liquidator since 2016.

After Enterprise’s success at trial on liability, the appeal centred on (i) whether credit of £32.3 million should be given against damages/equitable compensation Enterprise should receive for Mr Flowers’ breach of duty as director and (ii) whether insurance policies linked to the Icebreaker tax avoidance scheme were unenforceable on grounds of public policy and raising questions concerning the construction of an exclusion clause.

Enterprise was successful on all issues before the Privy Council, with the Board allowing its appeal on credits and dismissing the former director’s cross-appeal on Icebreaker.

The judgment provides essential guidance on the law relating to the extent to which a benefit received as a consequence of a defendant’s breach of obligations should be taken into account in the calculation of a claimant’s loss.

Read the full judgment here: Enterprise Insurance Company Plc (In Liquidation) v Andrew Flowers; and Andrew Flowers v Enterprise Insurance Company Plc (In Liquidation) (No 2) (Gibraltar) [2026] UKPC 40.

 

Related barristers

Charles Simpson

Call: 1996

Nigel Jones KC

Call: 1976 | Silk: 1999

Sarah McCann KC

Call: 2001 | Silk: 2026