Skip to main content

UK Cinema Association Ltd v Performing Rights Society Limited (CT 133/24)

Articles
16 Nov 2026

The Copyright Tribunal, with HHJ Hacon as the Chair, handed down on 08 October 2026 a ruling in favour of the Performing Rights Society in relation to its Tariff C. This Tariff governs the licensing of musical works in relation to film soundtracks and music played in other parts of cinemas.

Tariff C was first established in the UK in 1915, with amendments brought in successively, the most recent being in 2005. The previous dual-tariff that permitted payment of a percentage of ticket revenue operated via Percentage of Receipts, amounting to 1% of tickets sold, and then Price per Admission, which was a fixed amount that had risen successively to 7.33p by 2024. PRS sought to modernise the tariff such as to align it solely on customer admissions. The royalty rate itself was proposed to rise from 7.33p to 7.9p per admission, with the annual minimum fee per screen increasing from £75 to £131.50. A challenge to these changes under a reference to the Tribunal was made by the UK Cinema Association Ltd under s 119 of the Copyright, Designs, and Patents Act 1988 (“CDPA 1988”), representing around 230 cinema operators in the UK, over 90% of the market share. They resisted the increase, and in fact sought reductions to the royalty rates and retention of the dual-metric system.

The Tribunal had to consider the referral under s 119(3) CDPA 1988, where in effect they were asked to confirm or vary a referred licensing scheme. In that process, the tribunal also considered ss 129 and 135 CDPA 1988, which requires the Tribunal to guard against unreasonable discrimination through comparison to comparable licencing schemes and to consider all relevant considerations as it should in any case. In effect, the tariff needed to be reasonable in the circumstances.

The Tribunal considered first that their discretion was wide, and that they were entitled to consider three separate approaches: (a) willing licensor and willing licensee, (b) comparable licences, and (c) terms of previously agreed licences. Critically, the Tribunal was in the position not to make a presumption either to favour the existing tariff nor dismiss the new proposal. For the Tribunal, the focus was that it was an evaluative exercise directed towards in effect reasonableness of the proposal, requiring justification from the parties.

The Tribunal then turned its mind to several critical points between the parties. One of those key issues was the economic value of the licensed music under Tariff C. The Tribunal took the view that royalties bear some relationship to the value of the licensed rights but recognised that such a connection with music in film is difficult to measure. The Tribunal took the view that music, and its driver of people coming to the cinema, can be best assessed by admission rather than there being a “material impact” on the ticket price itself (see [75]).

The Tribunal also looked more broadly at the nexus underlying such licences in the reasonable assessment of royalties. The Tribunal agreed with the UKCA that there was no hard and fast rule about the nexus, but that it was a question of fact and degree whether there is sufficient connection between the use of the licensed right and profit generated by the licensee’s business to justify a royalty based on revenue. The Tribunal took the simpler view that the principle to be applied is that the question was whether the exercise of the rights licensed sufficiently influences the quantum of their revenue (see [104]). Further to that, the Tribunal said that it can be satisfied that where the licensee benefits from a greater use of copyright works being licensed, it may be appropriate and fair that without a linear relationship that the licensee pays in proportion to the extent of the use it makes of the relevant works.

The reasoning the Tribunal set out was decisive in coming to its determination in relation to whether to allow the UKCA to continue using the dual-metric system, under which it could choose between a percentage-of-receipts (“POR”) or the pence-per-admission model (“PPA”). The UKCA argued that the 2005 Tariff should be followed as a reasonable and flexible model that had been arrived at after extensive negotiations during 2003 and 2004.

The Tribunal took the view that “the correct way to assess the economic value of the music in a film is to view its contribution to the totality of the revenue that the film generates” (see [143]). The reality of cinema was that the revenue would depend significantly in accordance with factors that have nothing to do with music including local demographics, timing of the film, and local competition. In the eyes of the tribunal, music impacts ticket sales, not ticket prices. Therefore, the preference was to drop in favour to a single metric, as a simpler basis for royalties, which pointed the Tribunal towards a preference for a PPA model.

The Tribunal rejected UKCA’s arguments that the royalties under PPA should be reduced to reflect what was called “premiumisation” within the cinema sector, adverse trading conditions, or a divergence between the POR and PPA methodologies as evidenced by the expert evidence provided to the Tribunal. None of those factors were deemed by the tribunal to justify recalibration of the royalty rate as set out under Tariff C. PRS did attempt to argue that there was a greater “music density” in films now than there used to be, therefore increasing economic value. However, the Tribunal had “no evidence that the cinemas have received any greater economic benefit as a consequence but we accept that proving that they have – in fact proving anything about economic benefit – would have been difficult” (see [191]). However, the Tribunal was satisfied that there was a logic to some increase, coming to a determination that 7.25% would be appropriate.

Finally, in terms of key topics, the tribunal also considered the application of Tariff C to Cinematic Presentations of Live Music Events (“CPLMEs”). The Tribunal took the view that with these kinds of performances, it was likely that there was a much stronger connection between the music performed and the revenues generated. Therefore, for this specific type of performance, a receipts-based model was more appropriate. Therefore, retention of a POR model and increasing the rate to 4% was deemed appropriate. Booking fees for CPLMEs were also included.

The Tribunal ultimately ordered that ordinary film exhibitions should be licensed under a single PPA tariff at a base rate of 7.9 pence per admission, indexed annually by CPIH. The existing 4% prompt-payment discount was retained (see [216]-[224]).

Learnings from the Tribunal

There are some critical practical takeaways from this decision, particularly as matters referred to the Copyright Tribunal are relatively few and far between. The decision therefore is useful to see how the Tribunal might approach further referrals for relevant bodies. Crucially:

  1. The Tribunal will not accept that continuity is always the best approach. The Tribunal was not willing to make any presumptions in favour of the status quo and entrenched practices. For rights holders and licensees alike, the message is that historic licences and their negotiations are only evidence of reasonableness, not completely undeniable proof.
  2. Evidence of value matters over parties presenting evidence of use. PRS did establish that films contain more licensed music, but this was not completely determinative of the issue. Fundamentally, the Tribunal did not correlate increased use with increased value, thus establish the proportional increase separate to the evidenced increase in use of licensed music. Therefore, right holders seeking such royalty increases should consider commercial value generated by use beyond mere expanded use of a protected work.
  3. Finally, the legal principle of a nexus being drawn between the licensed intellectual property and the relevant drivers of the revenue stream forming the base of the royalty is key. Where there is a weak nexus between the IP and the identified revenue stream, the basis of the rate will be harder to justify. Therefore, when an entity is structuring a royalty arrangement, the relevant parties should test whether the chosen metric reflects the contribution made by the licensed rights.

The decision represents a significant outcome for PRS and its members. Moving forward, the decision provides this guidance on the principles governing the assessment of reasonable music licensing royalties, which stands as a unique opportunity for all licence holders and royalty streams a chance to consider their own approaches. The balance between rightsholders and those who use them is always a question of reasonableness between those parties; the Copyright Tribunal has made clear that the economics of music licensing should not be treated as merely background noise.


Article written by Thomas Hood.

Author

Thomas Hood

Call: 2024

Disclaimer

This content is provided free of charge for information purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied on as such. No responsibility for the accuracy and/or correctness of the information and commentary set out in the article, or for any consequences of relying on it, is assumed or accepted by any member of Chambers or by Chambers as a whole.

Contact

Please note that we do not give legal advice on individual cases which may relate to this content other than by way of formal instruction of a member of Gatehouse Chambers. However, if you have any other queries about this content please contact:

Ashley Allen
Ashley Allen Head of MarketingTel: 020 7691 0032